Menu Close

Kitchen Cabinets Costs: Framed vs. Frameless Pros & Cons

kitchen cabinets

If you’ve decided to do a kitchen remodeling project, you know the biggest part of the design will be the cabinets.

Not only the new cabinets need to be aesthetically pleasing, but they also need to be functional and appropriate.

If you can find well-built cabinets made made of quality material, then you’ve hit the kitchen cabinet trifecta.

With all of the choices available today, it can be overwhelming to know where to start and what to choose. This guide will help you navigate the cabinet buying process including styles, materials, costs, and pros and cons of various options.

Cost

The total average cost (including materials and labor) to install European style frameless cabinets in a typical 10-by-10 kitchen will range between $4,750 to $6,750, depending on the choice of contractor doing the work, cabinet manufacturer, materials and your home’s location or the local real estate market dynamics.

Did you know? All else being equal, it will cost about $1,000 less to supply and install basic face-framed cabinets compared to frameless cabinets.

Framed cabinets can be more difficult to install, but they can be safely hung on uneven walls, making them more suitable for uneven wall layouts and oddly-shaped kitchens.

Framed cabinets are also available in a greater variety of styles and materials.

The pricing difference between the two kinds is mostly in the material cost of cabinets; Frameless Shaker Door style cabinets (material and supplies only) will cost between $3,500 to $4,000 for a typical 10-by-10 kitchen, while comparable cabinets with face frame will normally cost about $1000 less.

How to Approach the New Cabinetry Buying Process?

Before you start looking at anything for your new kitchen, pay attention to how you’re using your current kitchen.

  • What do you like about it?
  • What do you think needs to be improved?
  • What’s your family’s lifestyle?
  • Do you need more storage for pots and pans?
  • Do you need a big island for your family to gather around and eat breakfast or do homework?
  • Do you frequently host parties and need a beverage station?
  • Do you mostly eat out and just want your kitchen to look amazing?

Knowing what will improve the quality of your family’s life, as well as, the resale value of your home, is an important factor many people fail to consider.

Design Phase

kitchen design plans

Begin by looking online and in magazines to find inspirational kitchen photos. Don’t eliminate cabinets or designs you love just because you think you can’t afford it. There may be a way to incorporate the things you love most and still stay within your budget.

Next, take measurements and photographs of your existing space.

Once you have an idea in your head of what your dream kitchen will be, determine your budget. As you’re crunching the numbers remember to set aside 10-20% as a cushion for unforeseen expenses.

Big Box Store vs. Local Cabinet Gallery

For most homeowners walking into their local Home Depot or Lowe’s is like walking into their second home. It’s familiar and easy. You may even think that you’ll save money, but that’s not always the case.

Depending on your area, local cabinet galleries can match or beat the prices of big box stores. Plus, you can get much more value for your money.

First of all, kitchen cabinet specialists in the big box stores don’t come to your home, do a professional measurement, see your home to make design suggestions and oversee that installation is being done properly.

Secondly, the cabinetry isn’t always the same quality. Be aware that you may be comparing apples to oranges.

Lastly, designers and custom cabinetry providers will normally go above and beyond to make sure you’re fully educated on your options, are happy with your choices and will help with the overall look of the kitchen, even if they’re only hired to do your cabinets.

Remember, these are people who love what they do so much that they opened their own business and are part of your community. Plus, the outcome of the project is more personal to them because their names and reputations will be attached to it.

Deciding on Quality

Knowing what to look for in quality cabinets, which areas you can save money and which areas you shouldn’t, will help you make an educated decision on what cabinets are best for you.

white kitchen cabinets

Most people have experience buying furniture, so it’s easier to know when to buy quality furniture and when it’s not as important.

For example, if you’re purchasing items for a dorm room or college apartment, then quality isn’t a priority. Those items are temporary and don’t need to last.

However, once you’ve bought your own home, you buy quality furniture meant to be durable. Since replacing kitchen cabinets is considerably more difficult than replacing an old futon with a high-quality sofa, it’s something you want to do correctly the first time.

Sometimes that means putting off your remodeling project until your budget allows you to get higher quality cabinets.

Cabinet Types

  • Framed, Inset and Frameless
  • Stock, Semi-Custom and Custom cabinets
  • Construction
  • Warranty
  • Environmentally-Friendly

Framed Cabinets

framed cabinet door

Framed cabinets have a face frame which is typically ¾” thick by 1-1/2” wide solid wood that’s attached to the front of the cabinet box. Cabinet doors and drawers are then attached to the cabinet frame.

Advantages

  • Strength
  • Easier to install
  • Larger selection
  • More design flexibility

Disadvantages

  • Less interior space than frameless cabinets
  • Face frame is visible behind doors, even with full overlay

Framed Cabinet Types

  • Overlay – Half Overlay and Full Overlay
  • Inset

Full Overlay vs. Half Overlay

A full or half overlay cabinet will have the same interior space, but the doors and drawer fronts are sized differently and change the appearance of the cabinet.

Full Overlay

full overlay cabinets

The door and drawer front overlap the face frame. There’s a very small reveal of the face frame behind it (about ¼”). It’s the most popular style of cabinetry.

Half Overlay

half overlay cabinets

The door and drawer front overlap the face frame ½”. It’s less expensive than full overlay.

Inset Cabinets

inset kitchen cabinets

Inset cabinets have the door set flush with the face frame.

Advantages

  • Very desirable look
  • Made with precision
  • Excellent way to show off fancy or unique hardware

Disadvantages

  • More expensive than overlay cabinets
  • No wiggle room for error
  • Humidity can affect performance

Frameless Cabinets

frameless cabinets

Frameless cabinets, also known as European, have a more modern look. Cabinet doors are attached directly to the box since there’s no frame. Often, but not always, frameless cabinets can be an indication of poorly built cabinets.

Advantages

  • More interior capacity
  • Cleaner lines for a modern look

Disadvantages

  • Harder to install
  • Can indicate a poor-quality cabinet
  • Not as stable as a framed cabinet
  • Limitations on design

Solid Wood vs. Engineered Wood

Different parts of the cabinet are made from different types of wood.

Face Frame

The face frame is typically made of solid wood. This allows for greater screw holding strength to attach the doors to the cabinet.

Doors

kitchen cabinet door samples

Door Frame: Typically made of solid wood

Center Panel: Can be made of several types of materials

Sides, Back, Bottom and Shelves: Can be made of several types of materials

Engineered Wood Types

Plywood

plywood

Plywood is made from thin layers of wood veneer that are glued together. The alternating sheet layers are rotated 90 degrees to give strength.

If you choose plywood construction, be sure to look for:

  • Several layers, at least 7-ply for ¾” thickness
  • Quality edges with no gaps between the layers
  • Low off gassing certifications such as, ULEF (Ultra-Law-Emitting formaldehyde), NAF (No added formaldehyde) and CARB (California Air Resource Board) compliant.

Advantages

  • Stronger
  • Less sensitive to moisture
  • Lighter weight than other engineered wood

Disadvantages

  • Beware of imported plywood. It’s used by several cabinet companies to save costs, but the binding agents used to produce them often times contain toxic chemicals, such as formaldehyde
  • Good plywood is 10-20% costlier than engineered wood
  • Plywood can warp

MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard)

MDF board

A composite panel product typically consisting of cellulose fibers combined with a synthetic resin or other suitable bonding system, joined together under heat and pressure.

Advantages

  • Sometimes preferred for painted cabinetry
  • The painted finish is smoother than solid wood or veneer
  • Less costly than solid wood

Disadvantages

  • Can swell if exposed to moisture

Particle Board

particle board

A composite panel product consisting of cellulosic particles of various sizes that are bonded together with synthetic resin or binder under heat and pressure.

Advantages

  • Smoother and more consistent
  • Less likely to warp than plywood
  • Less expensive than plywood

Disadvantages

  • More susceptible to moisture damage
  • Heavier

Veneer

veneer

A thin layer of real wood that is applied to sub material

Advantages

  • Takes stain more consistently
  • Less susceptible to swelling and shrinking with humidity
  • Costs less than solid wood

Disadvantages

  • Susceptible to water damage
  • Requires more maintenance
  • Cannot be repaired
  • Susceptible to cracks

Solid Wood

solid wood cabinet doors

Solid wood doors are considered the best. They’re generally ½” to ¾’’ thick.

Advantages

  • Stronger and more sturdy
  • Appearance
  • Higher quality

Disadvantages

  • A center door panel can consist of several pieces of wood which will each accept stain differently.
  • Solid wood door will swell and shrink with humidity.

Which Wood is Best for Cabinets?

You may believe that using solid wood on all parts of your cabinetry is best, but it’s not.

Understand that water will damage any wood product, regardless of whether or not you use solid wood or engineered wood. However, some engineered wood has been created to withstand the damage from humidity.

Although plywood is the best engineered wood, it can de-laminate when wet and can warp. If your budget allows, it’s always better to have good quality plywood especially in rooms that will be constantly exposed to high humidity levels.

Save money by using a lower grade material on the cabinet box. They won’t show once countertops are installed.

Use the money you’re saving to invest in an accessory or detail that you’ll use every day. If your cabinet manufacturer provides a lifetime warranty, you’ll be covered.

Drawer Box Construction

cabinet drawer construction

Look for a solid wood drawer box with dovetail joints and undermount drawer glides with smooth operation. Blum is considered the best.

Stock vs. Semi-Custom vs. Custom

Stock Cabinets

stock kitchen cabinets

Stock cabinets are pre-made and ready to install. They’re most often associated with off-the-shelf products at big box retailers. There’s often little selection, but you can get it quickly.

Stock cabinets generally are smoke and mirrors. They may look pretty, but they generally don’t have good quality.

Semi-Custom

semi custom cabinets

Semi-custom cabinets are base cabinets with extra detailing options. The options vary among manufacturer. Some offer custom sizes, but only with standard finishes and door styles. Others offer custom sizes and have a variety of wood types, finishes and styles.

Semi-custom cabinets are normally are suitable for mid-range to high-end budgets.

Custom

custom cabinets

Custom means made to personal order.

A local cabinet maker or wood worker makes cabinets built exactly to specifications. While many think of these as the highest level of cabinets, that may not always be the case.

Unless you’re remodeling an old home and wanting to maintain the era of the original home, local custom built cabinetry isn’t always the best choice.

While the construction will most likely be amazing, you may, in some cases, lose on the overall quality because of the finish and warranty. Local cabinet makers have an average warranty of two years, whereas high quality cabinet manufacturers have a lifetime warranty.

Warranty

Warranties are an indication of how long a manufacturer expects their product to last. If there is no warranty or even a 1-5 year warranty, you’re purchasing temporary cabinets because they’ll need to be replaced very soon.

For mid-range to high-quality cabinetry, you should be getting a lifetime warranty.

Environmentally-Friendly Cabinets

KCMA logo

Most, if not all, cabinet manufacturers in the U.S. have become green companies. Some even have tree planting programs to replace trees used in the manufacturing of their cabinets.

These companies were started by wood makers years ago and have grown into large cabinetry manufacturing companies. Many are still family owned and operated.

According to Barbara French of French’s Cabinet Gallery, “It’s always best to choose high quality cabinetry manufactured in the U.S. of materials made in the U.S. They’re safe to have in your home, they’re green and better for our environment.

Consumers should beware of cheaply built cabinetry coming from China. There is a history of toxic outgassing from these products due to no environmental control in China. Plus, the overall quality is very low. The cabinetry nor the finishes last. It’s all about cheap pricing.

If I may quote two very famous people:

‘Price is what you pay. Value is what you get.’   — Warren Buffet

“The bitterness of poor quality, remains long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten.’ — Benjamin Franklin”

I couldn’t have said it better, but I do believe you get what you pay.

To ensure you’re getting eco-friendly cabinetry look for these certifications:

  • LEED: Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design
  • CARB: California Air Resource Board
  • KCMA standards: Kitchen Cabinet Manufacturers Association

Whether you decide to go with lower grade cabinetry or high-end, quality cabinets, it will be well worth your time to speak to a professional kitchen designer to make sure you’re heading in the right direction. Once your project is complete, host a party and enjoy your new space!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: